The relationships between prey utilization and jaw biomechanics were e
xplored in two Caribbean populations (La Parguera and Mona Island) of
four trigger-fishes. The volumetric contribution of major prey types a
nd six biomechanical features of the jaws that characterize biting str
ength were contrasted between populations. At Mona, Xanthichthys ringe
ns ate 45% benthic organisms, whereas conspecifics at La Parguera fed
exclusively on plankton. Balistes vetula at Mona consumed 63% soft and
nonelusive invertebrates, in contrast to their La Parguera conspecifi
cs, which consumed 62% hard prey. Differences in diet between populati
ons were associated with differences in jaw biomechanics. Xanthichthys
al Mona had jaw muscles, bones, and closing-lever ratios larger than
those of fish at La Parguera, indicating a stronger bite. Balistes at
Mona had 50% smaller jaw bones, muscles, and closing-lever ratios than
their La Parguera conspecifics, indicating a weaker but swifter bite.
Melichthys niger and Cantherhines macrocerus ate similar prey at the
two locations and showed little difference in trophic anatomy. We hypo
thesize that the interpopulation differences in morphology are induced
by the activities of feeding on different prey and enhance the feedin
g ability of fishes for locally dominant prey. Plasticity of the feedi
ng mechanism may be a widespread attribute of fish feeding systems tha
t promotes the ability of species to occupy multiple habitat types suc
cessfully.