H. Menninger et al., PROGRESSION AND REPAIR IN RADIOGRAPHS OF HANDS AND FOREFEET IN EARLY RHEUMATOID-ARTHRITIS, Journal of rheumatology, 22(6), 1995, pp. 1048-1054
Objective. To evaluate radiographs of patients with early rheumatoid a
rthritis (RA) for progression and repair. Methods. Radiographs of hand
s and forefeet over 3 years were evaluated at 34 joints based on the m
odified Larsen-index, the number of joints with erosions, the area of
osseous defects including erosions and cysts, the radiologic activity
of lesions and - in relation to preceding status - the number of joint
s with qualitative radiologic improvement or deterioration, respective
ly, not necessarily seen by the other methods. Results. Counting of jo
ints with erosions and assessment of the area of osseous defects yield
ed the most impressive results for disease progression with the number
of eroded joints being the simplest method. Reparative phenomena incl
uded recortication, ''filling in'' and diminution in size of erosions
and paraarticular cysts, newly developing demarcation of a previously
indistinct articular outline, and the increase in trabecular structure
in the vicinity of erosions. The evaluation of qualitative changes sh
owed reparative phenomena with increasing frequency involving up to 9.
3% of the joints during the 3rd year, compared with 7.1% of the deteri
orating joints. Conclusion. Progression in early RA can be quantitated
easily by counting joint erosions. This method appears to be more sen
sitive than Larsen's approach. Repair can be shown early in the course
of the disease (as early as the second 6-month observation period) by
assessing both radiologic activity and qualitative changes, which are
not necessarily apparent in the foregoing quantitative methods. Repar
ative phenomena associated with healing of erosions and cysts can be n
oted increasingly during continuous longterm observation. Evaluation f
or healing phenomena should be standardized and considered for inclusi
on in therapeutic trials of RA.