This observational study utilized modified mark and recapture techniqu
es to examine the reliability of moribund fish caught at the surface o
f the water as indicators of the disease status of commercial salmon f
arms in British Columbia, Canada. The results indicate that the vast m
ajority of fish captured at the surface are truly moribund, but that t
he pattern of disease in these fish can be significantly different fro
m that seen in moribund fish not accessible to capture from the surfac
e. In some cases, estimates of the proportional mortality attributed t
o specific disease categories differed by 30% between surface-caught f
ish and dead fish. The small number of fish caught at the surface make
s it difficult to detect disease of low prevalence. In addition, the l
ow proportion of total mortalities accessible to surface capture prior
to their death makes extrapolation of disease data derived from surfa
ce samples to the entire pen tenuous. We conclude that samples of surf
ace-catchable fish do not necessarily reveal the true disease pattern
of a seapen and that future studies should be directed towards develop
ing additional methods of disease monitoring and investigation on seaf
arms such as mortality surveys and behavioural observations.