Pa. Mckinney et al., REGISTRATION QUALITY AND DESCRIPTIVE EPIDEMIOLOGY OF CHILDHOOD BRAIN-TUMORS IN SCOTLAND 1975-90, British Journal of Cancer, 70(5), 1994, pp. 973-979
Children (0-14 years) with malignant brain and central nervous system
(CNS) rumours (ICD9 191 and 192) were listed from the Scottish Cancer
Registration Scheme for the years 1975-90. These cases formed the basi
s for validation and verification procedures aimed at providing a comp
lete and accurate data set for epidemiological analyses. A variety of
data sources were cross-checked to optimise ascertainment, and resulti
ng from this 5.7% of validated cases were found on the cancer registry
with diagnostic codes outside the ICD-9 range 191-192. A further 8.4%
were newly registered cases. Analyses were conducted on the validated
data set showing a significant temporal increase in incidence rates o
ver the 16 year study period with an average annual percentage change
of + 2.6%. Large-scale geographical heterogeneity was also found, with
a particularly high incidence in the Fife and Lothian areas and a low
incidence in Grampian. Examination of associations with socioeconomic
status, using the Carstairs deprivation index, revealed a rising tren
d in incidence strongly linked to areas with increasing levels of affl
uence. Our results suggest that for studies of childhood CNS tumours v
alidation of cancer registry data is necessary and large-scale geograp
hical variation and socioeconomic factors should be taken into account
in any investigation of distribution in small geographical areas.