Objectives: The relationship between menstrual and bowel symptoms, the
overlap between the diagnoses of dysmenorrhea (DYS) and functional bo
wel disorder (FBD), and markers that may be useful in discriminating f
unctional bowel disorders from DYS were studied in 383 women (20-40 yr
of age). Methods: All women completed the NEO Personality Inventory a
t intake and completed the Moos' Menstrual Distress Questionnaire and
a bowel symptom inventory every 3 months for 12 months. Prostaglandin
levels were measured in vaginal dialysate on the first day of menses.
Results: DYS was diagnosed in 19.8% of the total sample. Functional bo
wel disorder, defined as abdominal pain with altered bowel function, w
as diagnosed in 61% of the DYS group compared with 20% of controls (p
< 0.05). Neuroticism scores were significantly higher in subjects with
functional bowel disorder with or without DYS. However, bowel symptom
s were significantly correlated with menstrual symptoms even after sta
tistically controlling for the effects of neuroticism. Painful menses
and water retention distinguished the DYS group from the functional bo
wel disorder group. Prostaglandin levels were elevated in women with D
YS, but did not consistently differentiate the diagnostic groups. Conc
lusions: The strong covariation of menstrual and bowel symptoms, along
with the overlap in diagnoses of DYS and function bowel disorder, sug
gest a common physiological basis.