Lj. Gonzalezmontaner et al., RIFABUTIN FOR THE TREATMENT OF NEWLY-DIAGNOSED PULMONARY TUBERCULOSIS- A MULTINATIONAL, RANDOMIZED, COMPARATIVE-STUDY VERSUS RIFAMPICIN, Tubercle and lung disease, 75(5), 1994, pp. 341-347
Setting: Patients with newly-diagnosed drug-sensitive, radiographicall
y active and bacteriologically confirmed pulmonary tuberculosis recrui
ted at 6 centres in Argentina, Brazil and Thailand. Objective: To asse
ss the efficacy, tolerability and toxicity of two regimens containing
different daily dosages of rifabutin in comparison with rifampicin.Des
ign: Multicentred, randomised, comparative study. In each group, study
medications were administered daily for 6 months combined with isonia
zid (6 months), and with pyrazinamide and ethambutol (both stopped aft
er 2 months). Treatment success patients were followed-up for up to 2
years. Results: A total of 520 patients were enrolled and randomly ass
igned to receive either rifampicin (n = 175), or rifabutin 150 mg (n =
174) or rifabutin 300 mg (n = 171). Considering all patients with pos
itive baseline culture, the success rates at the last valid observatio
n for each patient were 89%, 94% and 92% in the rifampicin, rifabutin
150 mg, and rifabutin 300 mg groups, respectively. The median time to
culture conversion was comparable in the 3 groups and was 34 days for
rifampicin and 37 days for each of the rifabutin groups. During the dr
ug-free follow-up period, one relapse occurred in the rifampicin group
, and two in each of the rifabutin groups. The 3 treatment schedules a
ppeared well tolerated. No patients had to discontinue therapy because
of an adverse event in the rifabutin 150 mg group, compared to one in
the rifampicin and 5 in the rifabutin 300 mg group. Conclusion: All 3
regimens proved effective and well tolerated. Rifabutin at 150 mg/d s
howed the best risk-to-benefit ratio, in that this group had the highe
st proportion of patients completing treatment, the highest bacteriolo
gical conversion rates and the lowest incidence of adverse events.