Ja. Pedit et Ct. Miller, HETEROGENEOUS SORPTION PROCESSES IN SUBSURFACE SYSTEMS .1. MODEL FORMULATIONS AND APPLICATIONS, Environmental science & technology, 28(12), 1994, pp. 2094-2104
The development of an appropriate model for sorption processes in natu
ral systems has proven elusive. We hypothesize that standard determini
stic models cannot capture the inherent variability in most natural sy
stems. This work responds tb deficiencies in current models by formula
ting two classes of sorption models: an extended set of deterministic
models based upon a generalized multiple domain concept and a class of
stochastic models. Stochastic sorption models are formulated to descr
ibe microscale variability, which may be interparticle or intraparticl
e in origin, in terms of both sorption equilibrium and rate properties
. Stochastic model formulations treat sorption equilibrium and rate pr
operties as continuously distributed random variables described by log
normal or T probability density functions. Long-term sorption equilibr
ium and rate data are shown for a herbicide on a subsurface material.
Results from parameter estimation for 16 different rate models applied
to the data set are summarized. Model-data comparisons show a range o
f agreement betwe en individual model fits and experimental data, with
several trends evident: diffusion models outperformed first-order mod
els; the addition of an instantaneously sorbing fraction significantly
improved model-data agreement; multiple-particle class models more cl
osely fit the data than single-particle class models, without an incre
ase in the number of fitted parameters; and stochastic first-order mod
els agreed well with the data.