Background: The standard method to measure gastric acid secretion is t
he aspiration of gastric juice. A noninvasive breath test after applic
ation of magnesium has been proposed. The aim of this study was to mod
ify the method, to possibly improve the discriminatory value of the te
st in comparison with intubation tests. Methods: We measured the time
course of the reaction of magnesium and gastric acid in vitro and dete
rmined the gastric hydrogen kinetics in humans by insufflation of hydr
ogen into the stomach and measuring its reappearance in the exhaled ai
r. Thereafter, a comparison of the breath test and the intubation test
was done in IO healthy volunteers in different secretory states. Resu
lts: After hydrogen insufflation 31.4% reappeared in 90 min (16.3% exh
aled, rest belched). Discriminant analysis showed that the intubation
test had a good discriminatory power. On the other hand, the breath te
st failed to distinguish between different secretory states (stimulati
on, inhibition, and intermediate). Conclusion: Whereas the intubation
test discriminated between high and low acid secretion, the breath tes
t did not. This test therefore seems, at least as performed here, unsu
itable as a diagnostic test of gastric acid secretion.