Efficacy trials of prophylactic HIV vaccines will be among the most di
fficult clinical trials ever attempted. Not only will there be challen
ges with the recruitment and retention of high-risk uninfected individ
uals, there will be many statistical challenges to the design, conduct
, analysis, and interpretation of these trials. General features of an
efficacy trial are described, including choice for the primary endpoi
nt and testing for and estimating vaccine efficacy. Secondary objectiv
es of trials are also discussed. These include determining the correla
tes of protective immunity, assessing the impact of HIV genetic variat
ion on vaccine efficacy, and using biological markers such as viral lo
ad and CD4(+) lymphocyte cell count to gain insight on a vaccine's abi
lity to prevent or delay disease. The use of biological markers as sur
rogates for disease outcome is discussed. Last, trial designs for stud
ying several candidate vaccines or other HIV prevention strategies in
a single trial are examined.