Zm. Zhang et H. Kohn, CHEMICAL, BIOCHEMICAL, AND BIOLOGICAL STUDIES ON SELECT C(1) TRIOL MODIFIED BICYCLOMYCINS, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 116(22), 1994, pp. 9815-9826
To determine the importance of the C(1) triol group to bicyclomycin (1
)-mediated transformations we prepared the bicyclomycin diastereomers
6 (C(1')-R, C(2')-S) and 7 (C(1')-S, C(2')-R), in which the stereochem
ical configuration at C(1') and C(2') in the triol group in 1 (C(1')-S
, C(2')-S) was reversed, and the C(1') ketone analogue 8 (C(2')-S), in
which the stereogenic center at C(1') in 1 was removed. Synthesis of
6 and 8 proceeded from C(1') ketobicyclomycin C(2'), C(3') acetonide (
10). Reduction (NaBH4, CeCl3) of 10 produced a diastereomeric mixture,
that, after separation and removal of the acetonide protecting group,
gave 6. Correspondingly, deprotection of 10 gave 8. Bicyclomycin anal
ogue 7 was prepared by dissolving the known bicyclomycin C(2'), C(3')
epoxide (13) in dilute methanolic sulfuric acid; this process produced
the novel [O(9)-C(2')]cyclized bicyclomycin (14). Compound 14 formed
with inversion of the C(2') center. Subsequent aqueous acid hydrolysis
yielded 7. Data documenting the proposed reaction pathways and struct
ures for compounds 6-8 are presented. The stability of bicyclomycin an
alogues 6-8 and 1 in deuterium oxide (pD 5.6-5.8, 7.4, 9.2-9.4) and in
DMF-d(7) solutions were examined. Compounds 7 and 8 were stable under
these conditions (room temperature, 14 days), whereas bicyclomycin un
derwent noticeable change only in basic deuterium oxide. Corresponding
ly, 6 was rapidly converted (t(1/2) < 30 h) to a new set of products i
n both acidic and basic deuterium oxide as well as in DMF-d(7). The fa
cility of these conversions have been attributed in part to the role o
f the C(1) triol substituent in the ring opening of the C(6) hemiketal
group in 6. All three bicyclomycin analogues reacted with ethanethiol
at the C(5)-C(5a) exomethylene unit at rates comparable to 1 in buffe
red (''pH'' 8.0-8.5) THF-H2O (3:1) mixtures. The products generated fr
om 6 and 7 were similar to those previously determined for 1, except f
or the configuration of the C(1') and C(2') substituents, whereas 8 yi
elded the novel piperidine adduct 33. The ethanethiol-8 reaction proce
eded easily in spite of earlier projections that the C(1') hydroxyl gr
oup in bicyclomycin was required for exomethylene modification. Simila
rly the corresponding C(2'), C(3') acetonide of 8, 10, readily underwe
nt reaction with ethanethiol. Significantly, compounds 6 and 7 only pa
rtially (25-35%) inhibited rho-dependent hydrolysis of ATP at the conc
entration levels observed to block ATPase activity by 1, and no inhibi
tion of ATP hydrolysis was detected for 8. Our previous studies establ
ished that the primary site of bicyclomycin action in Escherichia coli
is the cellular protein transcription termination factor rho. Similar
ly, none of the three compounds exhibited antibiotic activity at a con
centration of 1200 mu g/mL, using a filter disc assay. These cumulativ
e results suggested that key interactions existed between the C(1) tri
ol group in bicyclomycin and the antibiotic binding site in rho, which
are necessary for drug utilization and function.