Rj. Dunlop et al., ON WITHHOLDING NUTRITION AND HYDRATION IN THE TERMINALLY ILL - HAS PALLIATIVE MEDICINE GONE TOO FAR - A REPLY, Journal of medical ethics, 21(3), 1995, pp. 141-143
Patients who are dying of cancer usually give up eating and then stop
drinking. This raises ethical dilemmas about providing nutritional sup
port and fluid replacement. The decision-making process should be base
d on a knowledge of the risks and benefits of giving or withholding tr
eatments. There is no clear evidence that increased nutritional suppor
t or fluid therapy alters comfort, mental status or survival of patien
ts who are dying. Rarefy, subcutaneous fluid administration in the dyi
ng patient may be justified if the family remain distressed despite du
e consideration of the lack of medical benefit versus the risks. Some
cancer patients who are not imminently dying become dehydrated from re
versible conditions such as hypercalcaemia. This may mimic the effects
of advanced cancer. These conditions should be sought and fluid repla
cement therapy should be given along with the specific treatments for
the condition.