Rj. Roberts et al., REASONS FOR NON-UPTAKE OF MEASLES, MUMPS, AND RUBELLA CATCH-UP IMMUNIZATION IN A MEASLES EPIDEMIC AND SIDE-EFFECTS OF THE VACCINE, BMJ. British medical journal, 310(6995), 1995, pp. 1629-1632
Objectives-To investigate the reasons for poor uptake of immunisation
(non-immunisation) and the possible side effects of measles, mumps, an
d rubella vaccine in a catch up immunisation campaign during a communi
ty outbreak of measles. Design-Descriptive study of reasons for non-im
munisation and retrospective cohort study of side effects of the vacci
ne. Setting-Secondary schools in South Glamorgan. Subjects-Random clus
ter sample of the parents of 500 children targeted but not immunised a
nd a randomised sample of 2866 of the children targeted. Main outcome
measures-Reasons for non-immunisation; symptoms among immunised and no
n-immunised children. Results-Immunisation coverage of the campaign wa
s only 43.4% (7633/17 595). The practical problems experienced include
d non-return of consent forms (6698/17 595), refusal of immunisation (
2061/10 897 forms returned), and absence from school on day of immunis
ation (1203/8836 children with consent for immunisation). The most com
mon reasons cited for non-immunisation were previous measles infection
(145/232), previous immunisation against measles (78/232), and concer
n about side effects (55/232). Symptoms were equally common among immu
nised and non-immunised subjects. However, significantly more immunise
d boys than non-immunised boys reported fever (relative risk 2.31 (95%
confidence interval 1.36 to 3.93)), rash (2.00 (1.10 to 3.64), joint
symptoms (1.58; 1.05 to 2.38), and headache (1.31 (1.04 to 1.65)). Con
clusions-Many of the objections raised by parents could be overcome by
emphasising that primary immunisation does not necessarily confer imm
unity and that diagnosis of measles is unreliable. Measles, mumps, and
rubella vaccine is safe in children aged 11-15.