Jm. Klinck, THERMOHALINE STRUCTURE OF AN EDDY-RESOLVING NORTH-ATLANTIC MODEL - THE INFLUENCE OF BOUNDARY-CONDITIONS, Journal of physical oceanography, 25(6), 1995, pp. 1174-1195
A T-S volumetric census, with a resolution of 0.2 degrees C and 0.1 ps
u, for years 20-25 of the World Ocean Circulation Experiment Community
Modeling Effort eddy-resolving simulation of the equatorial and North
Atlantic Ocean, reveals how the thermohaline character of the model h
as changed from the initial conditions, which were taken from the Levi
tus climatology. Any changes in the thermohaline structure, other than
stirring, mixing, or geostrophic adjustment of smoothed climatology,
must be due to the boundary conditions, which are imposed at the surfa
ce and at four sponge layers (northern boundary, southern boundary, La
brador Sea and Mediterranean Sea), where water temperature and salinit
y are nudged toward climatological conditions. Several unrealistic the
rmohaline features appear in the solution, which can be traced to thes
e surface and lateral sponge boundary conditions. 1) Water masses from
the Arctic Ocean are overrepresented in the model. The volume transpo
rt across the northern sponge is twice the value estimated from observ
ations. The heat flux is approximately correct, while the salt flux is
large by a factor of 4. 2) Water masses from the South Atlantic are u
nderrepresented. The transport of water across the southern sponge is
about two-thirds of the observed value, but the salt flux is comparabl
e with estimates. However, the heat flux is only 10% of measured value
s due to a missing equatorward motion of warm surface waters. 3) Water
masses from the Labrador Sea and Baffin Bay are overrepresented. The
volume nux is twice that observed, while the heat flux from the sponge
is realistic. The salt flux is about 20% of the observed value. 4) Fi
nally, Mediterranean Water is underrepresented. Even though the volume
transport across the sponge is eight times the observed value, the ne
t salt flux is small by a factor of 400, leading to an insufficient pr
oduction of salt. All of these difficulties with the model T-S structu
re are traced to three general problems. First, the flow at the outer
edge of the sponges is strongly barotropic in spite of the fact that t
he temperature and salinity fields are from climatology. Part of the p
roblem with the sponges may be the smoothed nature of the climatology,
which has the effect of reducing density gradients, thereby reducing
geostrophic shears. In all cases, except the southern sponge, the volu
me transport across the sponge is two to eight times larger than the v
alue expected from other analyses or observations. Since the vertical
structure of the now is set by the climatology, the only way to create
this additional transport is through barotropic now. The reason for t
he additional transport is not entirely clear, but it may be due to th
e excessive vertical velocities that are demanded by the conversion pr
ocess in the sponges. These vertical motions create bound vortices in
the sponge layers that drive recirculation in the vicinity of the spon
ges;increasing the transport without changing the heat or salt flux. T
he second problem is due to geometric effects within the sponges. One
such problem is that Iceland blocks the exchange along the northern sp
onge. Another problem is that the ocean bathymetry is specified in the
sponge layer. For example, the inner Mediterranean sponge is so shall
ow (around 100 m) that there is very little area in which to modify th
e water. Similar conditions occur in the Labrador sponge where the wat
er is also 100 m deep. The third general problem is the use of relaxat
ion to climatology to represent surface freshwater fluxes, which leads
to unrealistic surface forcing if the currents are displaced from cli
matological locations. The combination of a displaced Gulf Stream and
the relaxation of surface salinity to climatology produces mode waters
that are unrealistically cool and fresh.