Plant community structure and soil characteristics were quantitatively
studied along forested cliff edges of the Niagara Escarpment in south
ern Ontario, Canada. The objective of the study was to try to differen
tiate between the effects of two gradients on vegetation structure: th
e environmental gradient between the cliff edge and dense forest, and
an anthropogenic gradient, generated by the presence of major hiking t
rails parallel to the cliff edges. Species frequencies were determined
along 69 transects distributed over eight sites with different amount
s of past and present trampling disturbance. The data were analyzed us
ing cluster and ordination analysis as well as analyses of variance. T
he results showed that soil characteristics were the major influence o
rganizing the vegetation of cliff-edge forests and that soil propertie
s and plant community structure were more strongly influenced by anthr
opogenic factors than by the environmental gradient between cliff edge
and forest. Trampled plots had some properties in common with cliff-e
dge plots. Species richness was highest at intermediate trail-use leve
ls; abandonment of heavily disturbed trails resulted in the restoratio
n of species richness, but most new colonizing plants were disturbance
-tolerant ruderals. Soil properties did not completely recover even af
ter 10 years of trail abandonment. The results suggest that the curren
t use of cliff edges along the Niagara Escarpment is nonsustainable, a
nd reversing its effects on cliff-edge forest structure may take a con
siderable amount of time.