The density of woody plants has increased in grasslands throughout the
world, but the cause has been elusive, although changes in herbivory
seem central. In this study, the importance of relative time of planti
ng and clipping of Bouteloua curtipendula, a C-4 grass, on Prosopis gl
andulosa, a woody seedling, was evaluated in a 2-yr field study in cen
tral Texas, USA. Secondarily, effects of planting date, presence of th
e woody seedling, and clipping of the grass on the growth of the grass
were evaluated. Relative growth rates (RGRs) of Prosopis glandulosa (
honey mesquite) seedlings grown alone were seasonal, generally high in
spring and decreasing as summer progressed. When P. glandulosa was pl
anted earlier than Bouteloua curtipendula (side-oats grama), the grass
had little or no effect on the woody seedling RGRs. However, the dry
mass of P. glandulosa increased 2.3 times when the grass was clipped b
ut was reduced 54% when the grass was unclipped. When the two species
were started at the same time and the grass was not clipped, P. glandu
losa RGRs decreased and remained zero over the 2 yr, dry mass was redu
ced 99.8%, and mortality was 80%. If both species were started at the
same time and the grass was clipped, 1st- and 2nd-yr growth of P. glan
dulosa was comparable to that of seedlings grown alone; however dry ma
ss was reduced 79%. When planted later than the clipped grass, dry mas
s of P. glandulosa was reduced 98% compared to dry mass when planted a
lone, while in unclipped plots there was 100% mortality. When B. curti
pendula was planted early in the growing season, clipping increased ab
oveground grass dry mass 1.63 times; there was no increase when the gr
ass was planted late. Evidence suggests that woody seedling growth in
undisturbed C-4 grasslands would be very limited, and establishment re
quires gap formation.