E. Mueller et al., HOMOLOGY-DEPENDENT RESISTANCE - TRANSGENIC VIRUS-RESISTANCE IN PLANTSRELATED TO HOMOLOGY-DEPENDENT GENE SILENCING, Plant journal, 7(6), 1995, pp. 1001-1013
Tobacco plants transformed with the RNA polymerase (RdRp) gene of pota
to virus X (PVX) that are extremely resistant to infection by potato v
irus X have previously been described. The PVX-resistant plants accumu
lated the RdRp protein at a lower level than fully susceptible plants
transformed with the same RdRp construct. In this paper the difference
between the PVX-resistant and susceptible transformed plants is inves
tigated and it is demonstrated that there are three associated phenoty
pes of the RdRp transgene that vary in parallel between transformed li
nes. These phenotypes are: accumulation of the transgenic RdRp RNA at
a low level; strain-specific resistance to PVX; and the ability of the
transgene to trans-inactivate homologous transgenes. This gene-silenc
ing potential of the transgenes conferring PVX resistance was illustra
ted by analysis of progeny from a cross between a transformant that wa
s extremely resistant to PVX and a second PVX-susceptible transformant
. In other transformants, in which the resistance was less extreme, th
e same three phenotypes were associated but in a transgene dosage-depe
ndent manner. The same association of strain-specific resistance and l
ow-level accumulation of the transgenic RdRp RNA was observed with pla
nts that were transformed with mutant or wild-type versions of the RdR
p gene. Strain-specific resistance was also produced in plants transfo
rmed with untranslatable versions of the RdRp transgene. Based on thes
e data it is proposed that homology-dependent gene silencing and trans
genic resistance to PVX may be due to the same RNA-based mechanism. An
undefined genomic feature is proposed to account for the variation in
the resistance and trans-inactivation phenotypes of different transfo
rmants. It is further proposed that this genome feature influences a c
ytoplasmic mechanism that degrades RNA with sequence homology to the s
ilencing transgene.