Pd. Nesbitt, 1ST AND 2ND CAREER CLERGY - INFLUENCES OF AGE AND GENDER ON THE CAREER-STAGE PARADIGM, Journal for the scientific study of religion, 34(2), 1995, pp. 152-171
The traditional age-graded, career-stage paradigm used to predict, exp
lain, and evaluate clergy career behavior, has been challenged by the
recent substantial influx of ordained second-career men and women. Thi
s analysis tests the validity of the paradigm for career trajectories
other than those of first-career men. The results, quantitatively eval
uating the career trajectories of 1,373 Episcopal and 196 Unitarian Un
iversalist men and women clergy ordained between 1920 and 1990, sugges
t that the two most relevant age-related demarcations for men are ordi
nation by the mid-thirties for senior-level attainment, and ordination
by age 50 for mid-level attainment. Career trajectories of women cler
gy show fewer age effects, likely due to the suppressing influence of
gender on opportunities for mobility and attainment. Consequently, age
-graded occupational paradigms are ineffective in explaining or predic
ting career dynamics for women clergy. Comparison of these two religio
us organizations suggests that denominational size and occupational st
ructure may influence the effect of age on clergy careers.