R. Eisinga et al., ORTHODOX RELIGIOUS BELIEFS AND ANTI-SEMITISM - A REPLICATION OF GLOCKAND STARK IN THE NETHERLANDS, Journal for the scientific study of religion, 34(2), 1995, pp. 214-223
The Glock and Stark theoretical framework on Christian beliefs and ant
i-Semitism implies that orthodox religious beliefs perpetuate secular
anti-Semitism via particularism and religious anti-Semitism. Several c
ritics have argued that the major weakness of this study is its failur
e to examine explanatory variables other than religious beliefs. This
paper addresses these issues using data from a 1990-91 national Dutch
survey. Although the results tend to support the assumption that nonre
ligious variables are far more important to the explanation of anti-Se
mitism and, too, that they attenuate the impact of Christian orthodoxy
, the effects of the latter are by no means spurious. The most importa
nt conclusion of this paper is therefore that there still is, in Holla
nd at least, a religious factor at work, albeit a modest one, generati
ng anti-Semitic beliefs.