S. Scheiner et T. Kar, THE NONEXISTENCE OF SPECIALLY STABILIZED HYDROGEN-BONDS IN ENZYMES, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 117(26), 1995, pp. 6970-6975
Ab initio calculations are used to test a recent suggestion that enzym
ic catalysis can be aided by strengthening of a hydrogen bond in a key
intermediate, occurring when this bond is shortened and the pK(a)'s o
f the two groups are equalized. The requisite amount of energy is not
available in electrically neutral H-bonds; no additional strengthening
can be accomplished by shortening such a bond. Interaction energies w
here one subunit is charged, on the other hand, can be very high. Thes
e bonds are intrinsically very short, and the proton transfer profile
contains a very low energy barrier. There is no special stabilization
associated with the disappearance of the transfer barrier or equalizat
ion of the pK(a)'s.