Rc. Fraser et al., USE OF VITAMIN-B-12 IN LEICESTERSHIRE PRACTICES - A SINGLE TOPIC AUDIT LED BY A MEDICAL AUDIT ADVISORY GROUP, BMJ. British medical journal, 311(6996), 1995, pp. 28-30
Objectives-To encourage active participation of Leicestershire general
practitioners and their staff in audit; to examine the use of vitamin
B-12 injections and to achieve a more appropriate use. Design-Impleme
ntation of an agreed audit protocol, with central analysis and feedbac
k of anonymous and aggregated data by a medical audit advisory group.
Setting-All 147 Leicestershire practices. Main outcome measures-Partic
ipation in the complete audit cycle, comparison of actual use of vitam
in B-12 injections with agreed criteria of use, and assessment of impr
ovement in use. Results-264 general practitioners (55% of all doctors
from 49% of all Leicestershire practices) completed both phases of the
audit cycle, and 321 (67%) completed phase 1 only. Twenty four (16%)
practices failed to participate from the outset, and a further 58 (35%
) dropped out at various stages. Only 10 of the 37 singlehanded practi
ces completed the audit, although 34 initially agreed to participate.
If singlehanded practices were excluded, 56% (61) of practices complet
ed both phases of the audit cycle. In total 1714 patients received B-1
2 injections. Appropriate use increased from 62% in phase 1 to 72% in
phase 2 of the audit; there was a 32% reduction in the number of patie
nts inappropriately receiving B-12 (521 to 352), and the proportion of
patients receiving B-12 at the correct frequency rose from 58% to 72%
. The proportion of patients in whom all the diagnostic criteria for p
ernicious anaemia were established before treatment with B-12 was 27%
in phase 1 and 28% in phase 2. Conclusion-Our study suggests that sing
le topic audits organised by a medical audit advisory group can encour
age large numbers of general practitioners to participate and can brin
g about changes in behaviour resulting in improvements in standards of
care. Nevertheless, advisory groups will need to devise strategies to
encourage even higher levels of involvement, most particularly from s
inglehanded practices.