Ka. Hawkins et al., COGNITION, NEGATIVE SYMPTOMS, AND DIAGNOSIS - A COMPARISON OF SCHIZOPHRENIC, BIPOLAR, AND CONTROL SAMPLES, The Journal of neuropsychiatry and clinical neurosciences, 9(1), 1997, pp. 81-89
Forty-six schizophrenic, 22 bipolar, and 26 normal control subjects we
re administered negative and positive symptoms scales and tests of cog
nitive function. Test performance was related to diagnosis and to posi
tive and negative symptom ratings within the schizophrenic group. Bipo
lar patients were significantly superior in cognitive status when comp
ared with all schizophrenic patients, but less so when compared only w
ith those who did not have key negative symptoms (affective nonrespons
ivity and poverty of speech). The schizophrenic patients with negative
symptoms displayed severe impairment, performing significantly worse
than the control, bipolar, and other schizophrenic subjects. Negative
symptoms thus are significantly implicated in the cognitive inferiorit
y of schizophrenic to bipolar patients. Although the data suggest bipo
lar patients may also have cognitive deficiencies, these findings are
inconclusive and require cross-validation.