B. Black et Tw. Uhde, PSYCHIATRIC CHARACTERISTICS OF CHILDREN WITH SELECTIVE MUTISM - A PILOT-STUDY, Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 34(7), 1995, pp. 847-856
Objective: To ascertain characteristics of children with selective mut
ism. Method: Subjects with selective mutism were evaluated by means of
parent and teacher rating scales and structured diagnostic interviews
. Results: Thirty children were evaluated. Mutism severity varied mark
edly in different environmental settings. Ninety-seven percent of the
subjects were diagnosed with social phobia or avoidant disorder of chi
ldhood or adolescence or both and 30% with simple phobia. No other psy
chiatric disorders were common. Parent and teacher rating scales showe
d high levels of anxiety symptoms, especially social anxiety, and low
levels of all other psychiatric symptoms. Anxiety and social anxiety s
everity correlated with mutism severity. First-degree family history o
f social phobia and of selective mutism, obtained by family history me
thod, was present in 70% and 37% of families, respectively. There was
no evidence of a causal relationship between psychologically or physic
ally traumatic experiences and development of selective mutism. Conclu
sions: Selective mutism may be a symptom of social anxiety, rather tha
n a distinct diagnostic syndrome. Further study of the characteristics
of children with selective mutism and their families is warranted.