Jm. Bullock et al., CARRYOVER EFFECTS ON INTERCLONAL COMPETITION IN THE GRASS HOLCUS-LANATUS - A RESPONSE-SURFACE ANALYSIS, Oikos, 72(3), 1995, pp. 411-421
The effects of past (carryover) and present (direct) clipping environm
ent on the competitive interaction between two clones of the grass Hol
cus Ianatus were investigated in a glasshouse experiment using respons
e surface analysis. Two carryover treatments, previous clipping or no
clipping, were applied to plants for eight weeks. Tillers from these p
lants were planted in mixtures of the two clones over a range of frequ
encies and tiller densities, between 44-40000 tillers m(-2). During th
e competition experiment two direct treatments, clipping or no clippin
g, were applied. Carryover and direct treatments were applied factoria
lly in two replicate blocks. After ten weeks of growth plant mortality
and yield of biomass and tiller number by each clone were measured in
each treatment. Plant mortality was very low. The biomass and tiller
yield data sets for each clone in each clipping treatment combination
were analysed using a non-linear competition model. Every data set gav
e an r(2) < 0.99. Statistical comparison of response surfaces showed s
ignificant clonal differences within each combination of carryover and
direct treatments in the model parameters for both biomass and tiller
number. The short-term outcome of competition was determined by calcu
lating the growth rates of clones, in terms of biomass accumulation an
d tiller production, using the model parameter estimates. In most clip
ping treatments the planting densities of the competitors affected the
outcome of competition. Both carryover treatment and direct treatment
significantly affected the model parameter estimates of both clones a
nd changed the equivalence coefficients of the competitive interaction
. The responses to the carryover treatment were affected by the direct
treatment and vice versa. Therefore, the short-term outcome of compet
ition and the effects of the competitor densities on the outcome were
different in each of the four treatment combinations. These results ma
y explain the high genotypic diversity previously observed in the stud
y population of H. lanatus. Spatial and temporal environmental heterog
eneity, e.g. in grazing levels, may cause intra-population variation i
n the outcome of interclonal competition and thus promote genotypic co
existence. Carryover effects from past environmental conditions will m
agnify this process, effectively increasing the environmental heteroge
neity experienced by the population.