This paper characterizes acyclic preference aggregation rules under va
rious combinations of monotonicity, neutrality, decisiveness, and anon
ymity, in the spirit of Nakamura's (1979) Theorem on the core of simpl
e games. Each of these characterizations can be seen to follow from Fe
rejohn and Fishburn's (1979) result on acyclic aggregation rules assum
ing only independence of irrelevant alternatives. We then state as cor
ollaries to these characterizations extant results such as Sen's (1970
) liberal paradox, Blau and Deb's (1977) theorem on the existence of v
etoers, and Brown's (1975) theorem on the non-emptiness of the collegi
um.