A required listserv, borders@uci.edu, electronically enhances composit
ion instruction for seven combined classes in an undergraduate course
on Argument and Research at the University of California at Irvine. E-
mail is a convenience for these students, easing access to research in
formation in the library and to their instructors and peers. Even more
importantly, the listserv's electronic community provides a forum whe
re students and instructors can model, rehearse, test the limits of, e
xchange, and reshape academic arguments. These seven instructors refle
ct in this paper on the objectives of their innovative approach and it
s implications For teaching and learning-particularly students' resist
ance to an inevitable electronic relocation of the teacher in cyberspa
ce. They also offer some practical suggestions based on their experien
ces.