Ma. Maslin et al., ESTIMATING THE CARBON TRANSFER BETWEEN THE OCEAN, ATMOSPHERE AND THE TERRESTRIAL BIOSPHERE SINCE THE LAST GLACIAL MAXIMUM, Terra nova, 7(3), 1995, pp. 358-366
Carbon dioxide records from polar ice cores and marine ocean sediments
indicate that the last glacial maximum (CGM) atmosphere CO2 content w
as 80-90 ppm lower than the mid-Holocene. This represents a transfer o
f over 160 GtC into the atmosphere since the LGM. Palaeovegetation stu
dies suggest that up to 1350 GtC was transferred from the oceans to th
e terrestrial biosphere at the end of the last glacial. Evidence from
carbon isotopes in deep sea sediments, however, indicates a smaller sh
ift of between 400 and 700 GtC. To understand the functioning of the c
arbon cycle this apparent discrepancy needs to be resolved. Thus, olde
r data have been reassessed, new data provided and the potential error
s of both methods estimated. New estimates of the expansion of terrest
rial biomass between the LGM and mid-Holocene are 700 GtC +/-> 300 GtC
, using the ocean carbon isotope-based method, compared with of 1100 G
tC +/-> 500 GtC using the palaeovegetation estimate. If these estimate
s of the carbon shift to the terrestrial biosphere are equilibrated wi
th the dissolved carbon in the oceans, and the CaCO3 compensation of t
he ocean is taken into account, then the glacial atmospheric CO2 would
have been between 50 (+/-30) ppm and 95 (+/-50) ppm higher. The glaci
al atmosphere therefore should have had a CO2 partial pressure of betw
een 330 and 375 mu atm. Hence, a rise of between 130 and 175 mu atm in
atmospheric CO2, rather than 80 mu atm, at the end of the last glacia
l must be accounted for.