This study documents the results obtained in 30 day patients undergoin
g open hernia repair under local infiltration block with patient-contr
olled sedation (group A) and 29 day patients undergoing laparoscopic h
ernia repair under general anaesthesia (group B). The mean operating t
ime was less in group) A (44.8 min) compared with group B (66.6 min) (
p < 0.0001). Similarly, stage 1 recovery room times were longer in gro
up B (98.1 min) than group A (45.1 min) (p < 0.0001). Time to discharg
e for group A (139.1 min) was significantly shorter than group B (224.
2 min) (p < 0.002), with more peri-operative complications occurring i
n group B and greater analgesic requirements. An open inguinal hernia
repair under local infiltration block is the optimal approach for unil
ateral non-recurrent herniae as a day surgical procedure. These result
s have important cost and efficiency implications.