Be. Wyslouzil et G. Wilemski, BINARY NUCLEATION KINETICS .2. NUMERICAL-SOLUTION OF THE BIRTH-DEATH EQUATIONS, The Journal of chemical physics, 103(3), 1995, pp. 1137-1151
We numerically solve the complete set of coupled differential equation
s describing transient binary nucleation kinetics for vapor-to-liquid
phase transitions. We investigate binary systems displaying both posit
ive and negative deviations from ideality in the liquid phase and obta
in numerical solutions over a wide range of relative rates of monomer
impingement. We emphasize systems and conditions that either have been
or can be investigated experimentally. In almost every case, we find
behavior consistent with Stauffer's idea that the major particle flux
passes through the saddle point with an orientation angle that depends
on the rates of monomer impingement. When this is true, the exact num
erical steady state nucleation rates are within 10%-20% of the predict
ions of Stauffer's analytical theory. The predictions of Reiss' saddle
point theory also agree with the numerical results over a wide range
of relative monomer impingement rates as long as the equilibrium vapor
pressures of the two pure components are similar, but Stauffer's theo
ry is more generally valid. For systems with strong positive deviation
s from ideality, we find that the saddle point approximation can occas
ionally fail for vapor compositions that put the system on the verge o
f partial liquid phase miscibility. When this situation occurs for com
parable monomer impingement rates, we show that the saddle point appro
ximation can be rescued by evaluating an appropriately modified nuclea
tion rate expression. When the two impingement rates differ significan
tly, however, the major particle flux may bypass the saddle point and
cross a low ridge on the free energy surface. Even in these rare cases
, the analytical saddle point result underpredicts the numerical resul
t by less than a factor of 10. Finally, we study the transition from b
inary to unary nucleation by progressively lowering the vapor concentr
ation of one component. Both Reiss' and Stauffer's rate expressions fa
il under these conditions, but our modified rate prescription remains
within 10%-20% of the exact numerical rate. (C) 1995 American Institut
e of Physics.