Little attention has been payed to the classification of psychotic sym
ptoms in dementia sufferers. This article compares the etiology of del
usions, visual hallucinations and delusional misidentification and exa
mines the value of factors generated from principal components analysi
s as a possible classificatory system in a group of 125 patients with
DSM-III-R dementia in contact with clinical services who were prospect
ively evaluated using standardized instruments to describe in detail i
ndividual psychotic symptoms. The assessment also included the Geriatr
ic Mental State Schedule, the History and Aetiology Schedule and the C
AMCOG. Delusions and visual hallucinations had a distinct cognitive pr
ofile as did delusions and delusional misidentification, although ther
e was an overlap between visual hallucinations and delusional misident
ification. Four factors were generated from principal components analy
sis. Three of these closely mirrored the 3 symptom groups delusions, v
isual hallucinations and delusional misidentification, although the ph
antom-boarder delusion was correlated with the visual hallucination fa
ctor and not delusional misidentification. The fourth factor included
visual hallucinations of relatives and delusions that relatives were i
n the house. This factor was strongly inversely associated with emotio
nal distress and could perhaps best be seen as a comfort phenomena. Th
e pattern of cognitive deficits and etiological associations of each o
f the factors were independent of one another, supporting the notion t
hat it is useful to consider them as separate entities.