The question is addressed whether cisplatin-based chemotherapy for ger
m cell cancer has the same efficacy in intratesticular and in extragon
adal sites. For this purpose, 7 patients with germ cell cancer, aged 1
6-35 years were analysed. Four of the patients had palpable testicular
tumors, 3 had occult testicular tumors. All presented with advanced d
isease and therefore received chemotherapy as the first step of treatm
ent. Orchiectomy was done in the later course. A significant clinical
response to chemotherapy was observed at the intratesticular tumor sit
e as well as at extragonadal sites in all patients. Orchiectomy specim
ens contained viable cancerous cells in 2 patients after two courses o
f chemotherapy while in 5 patients no invasive germ cell cancer was fo
und. Severe depression of germ cells was observed in all specimens. Te
sticular intraepithelial neoplasia (TIN; carcinoma in situ) persisted
in 4 patients, 1 of whom also had viable cancerous cells in the specim
en. Cisplatin-based chemotherapy is also active in intratesticular tum
ors but there seems to be a slightly different response of metastatic
germ cell cancer and intratesticular tumor. Tumor heterogeneity appear
s to be the most important reason for this different response. The low
er response of TIN to chemotherapy as compared to invasive testicular
cancer is probably due to a genetically determined lower sensitivity.
The blood-testis barrier might contribute a minor part to this phenome
non by modulating the intratubular concentrations of cytostatic compou
nds. The efficacy of cisplatin-based chemotherapy on invasive intrates
ticular tumors is not compromised by the blood-testis barrier. Primari
ly because of the possible persistence of TIN, all patients receiving
chemotherapy as the initial step of treatment for metastatic testicula
r germ cell tumor should undergo orchiectomy even if there is complete
systemic response.