A. Mecklinger et al., PROCESSING RELATIVE CLAUSES VARYING ON SYNTACTIC AND SEMANTIC DIMENSIONS - AN ANALYSIS WITH EVENT-RELATED POTENTIALS, Memory & cognition, 23(4), 1995, pp. 477-494
Event-related potentials were used to study how parsing of German rela
tive clauses is influenced by semantic information. Subjects read well
-formed sentences containing either a subject or an object relative cl
ause and answered questions concerning the thematic roles expressed in
those sentences. Half of the sentences contained past participles tha
t on grounds of semantic plausibility biased either a subject or an ob
ject relative reading; the other half contained past participles that
provided no semantic information favoring either reading. The past par
ticiple elicited an N400 component, larger in amplitude for neutral th
an for semantically biased verbs, but this occurred only in the case o
f subject relative clauses. More specific effects were obtained only f
or a subgroup of subjects, when these were grouped into fast and slow
comprehenders on the basis of their question-answering reaction times.
Fast comprehenders showed larger N400 amplitudes for neutral than for
semantically biased past participles in general and larger N400s for
the latter when there was a bias for an object relative reading as opp
osed to a subject relative reading. Syntactic ambiguity resolution, in
dicated by an auxiliary in sentence final position, was associated in
this subgroup with a positive component (P345), larger in amplitude fo
r auxiliaries indicating an object relative reading than for those ind
icating a subject relative reading. The latter component was independe
nt of semantically biasing information given by a preceding past parti
ciple. Implications of these findings for models of language comprehen
sion are considered.