S. Gronert et Jm. Lee, GAS-PHASE REACTIONS OF METHYLOXIRANE WITH HO- AND METHYLTHIIRANE WITHHO- AND HS- - AN AB-INITIO STUDY OF ADDITION AND ELIMINATION, Journal of organic chemistry, 60(14), 1995, pp. 4488-4497
For the title reactions, high-level ab initio calculations (MP2/6-31+G
*parallel to MP2/6-31f+G*) were used to characterize the potential en
ergy surfaces for nucleophilic addition at carbon (C-1 or C-2) and E2
elimination (anti or syn). In accord with gas phase experiments, elimi
nation is slightly favored over addition when HO- is the nucleophile.
In all the HO--induced eliminations, the constraints of the 3-membered
ring do not allow for periplanar transition states. When HS- is used,
the barrier to elimination is high and addition is the only viable pa
thway. Attack at the sulfur of thiirane (desulfurization) was also inv
estigated for HO- and HS-. Asynchronous reactions with relatively larg
e barriers are observed, and surprisingly, a stable, hypervalent sulfu
r intermediate is present in the reaction of HO- with thiirane. To ass
ess the effects of ring strain, calculations were also completed on th
e corresponding reactions of acyclic analogs (CH3CH2OCH3 and CH3CH2SCH
3). Although the additions of HO- involve early transition states, the
calculations suggest that similar to 75% of the ring strain is releas
ed at the transition state. Because the HO--induced eliminations are E
1cb-like, much less ring strain (similar to 30%) is released at the tr
ansition state. In contrast, the HS--induced eliminations have relativ
ely late transition states and a larger portion of the ring strain is
released.