Kj. Barriga et al., POPULATION SCREENING FOR GLUCOSE INTOLERANT SUBJECTS USING DECISION TREE ANALYSES, Diabetes research and clinical practice, 34, 1996, pp. 17-29
The purpose of this study was to develop a method of screening for imp
aired glucose tolerance and previously undiagnosed NIDDM that could be
used preliminary to the administration of an oral glucose tolerance t
est (OGTT) for final classification of glucose tolerance status. The p
urpose of a preliminary screening of this type would be to reduce the
number of OGTT's needed to identify cases of IGT and NIDDM in the popu
lation. We used NIDDM risk indicators and decision tree analysis metho
ds (CART software) to identify subgroups of the population at increase
d risk. We examined a population of Hispanic (n=583) and non-Hispanic
white (n=768) subjects without a prior history of diabetes. Subjects w
ere classified as normal, IGT or NIDDM (WHO criteria) based on results
from a 75 g oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT). Sensitivity (SEN) and
specificity (SPE) of the CART models were calculated using the OGTT a
s the 'gold standard.' Two approaches to screening were simulated. In
the simultaneous approach all risk variables were entered into CART mo
dels at once. In the serial approach, risk variables were grouped acco
rding to degree of effort required for data collection, and were enter
ed into CART models in stages. Fasting glucose, age and body mass inde
x (BMI) were selected as risk;variables by CART when simulating the si
multaneous approach (SEN=91%, SPE=55%). In the serial approach, CART u
sed age and BMI to eliminate 35% of the population from further screen
ing, and then used fasting glucose, glycohemoglobin, age and BMI to cl
assify the remaining higher risk subjects (SEN=85% SPE=64%). These mod
els suggest that screening for IGT and previously undiagnosed NIDDM ca
n be based on measurement of relatively simple indicators, and yet mai
ntain a level of both sensitivity and specificity acceptable for this
type of preliminary screening.