De. Busch et Sd. Smith, MECHANISMS ASSOCIATED WITH DECLINE OF WOODY SPECIES IN RIPARIAN ECOSYSTEMS OF THE SOUTHWESTERN US, Ecological monographs, 65(3), 1995, pp. 347-370
Throughout western North America, riparian ecosystem function has been
transformed by anthropogenic influences on riverine environments, Mod
ified hood frequency, duration, or intensity; depressed floodplain wat
er tables; and increased alluvium salinity have contributed to change
in riparian forest communities formerly dominated by Populus fremontii
and Salix gooddingii. The invasion of the naturalized arborescent shr
ub, Tamarix ramosissima, potentially alters competitive hierarchies an
d disturbance regimes in these riparian ecosystems. We evaluated the s
tructure and function of two southwestern riparian communities that di
ffered in the degree of streamflow perturbation to which they had been
subjected: the highly regulated lower Colorado River and the less tig
htly regulated Bill Williams River. Ordination analyses provided evide
nce that these riparian communities are structured along gradients rel
ating to moisture, salinity, disturbance from fire, and community matu
rity, with Colorado River sites being more xeric and saline than those
on the Bill Williams River. Foliar elemental analyses revealed high s
odium concentrations in Tamarix (Na:K ratio = 1.87) and in the native
shrub Tessaria sericea (Na:K = 1.56). Evaluation of tissue water relat
ions parameters showed that Tamarix had lower osmotic potentials than
sympatric woody taxa, helping to confirm that Tamarix is halophytic an
d probably capable of greater osmotic adjustment than native species.
Carbon isotopic discrimination (Delta) provided evidence for higher wa
ter use efficiency in Tamarix than in Populus, Salix, and Tessaria. Ta
marix Delta averaged over 1 parts per thousand less than that of the o
ther riparian taxa, Experimental removal of Tamarix from stands where
Salix was codominant resulted in growth augmentation, less negative wa
ter potentials, and higher leaf conductance in Salix, all providing ev
idence of interspecific competition. The persistence of Salix, but not
Populus, on the Colorado River appears to be due to greater water- an
d salinity stress tolerance in Salix than in Populus. A preponderance
of senescent Populus along the Colorado River is an indication that th
is formerly dominant species is effectively approaching local extincti
on in parts of this ecosystem.