D. Riemann et al., TREATMENT OF DEPRESSIONS BY SLEEP-DEPRIVA TION AND ADVANCE OF THE SLEEP PHASE, Fortschritte der Neurologie, Psychiatrie, 63(7), 1995, pp. 270-276
Total sleep deprivation (TSD) exerts beneficial but only transient eff
ects on mood in approximately 60% of the patients with a major depress
ive disorder (MDD). The positive effect of TSD is generally reversed a
fter the next night of sleep. A pilot study of our group indicated tha
t a consecutive one week phase advance of the sleep phase stabilized m
ood in more than half of the patients who responded to TSD. However, t
he majority of patients in our pilot study had been treated concomitan
tly with antidepressive medication. To exclude a possible synergistic
effect of simultaneous antidepressive medication and the sleep-wake ma
nipulation in the present study eleven medicated and sixteen drug-free
depressed patients were investigated. In two thirds of the patients r
elapse into depression after successful TSD could be prevented. This e
ffect seemed to be independent of adjunct antidepressant pharmacothera
py, Ten of these patients were studied polysomnographically prior to a
nd during the treatment. Data analysis revealed that during the advanc
e of the sleep phase no prolonged partial sleep deprivation took place
. At the end of the study REM % had even increased and REM latency was
still short in spite of clinical improvement, thus contradicting the
assumption that REM sleep suppression is a necessary prerequisite for
antidepressive therapy.