Control of nonpoint source pollution often requires regulation of inpu
ts, but first-best solutions are unattainable. Because inputs are moni
tored by different agencies and regulatory coordination can be costly,
It may be more practical to regulate single inputs. A cost-effectiven
ess approach to determining the best single-input tax policy is develo
ped and applied to the question of reducing nitrate leaching from lett
uce production in California. Water is the best single input to regula
te, and efficiency losses from this second-best approach appear not to
be great. Conditions for the welfare ranking of policies to be invari
ant to heterogeneity in production or leaching are identified.