Fifteen patients with a DSM-III-R diagnosis of panic disorder with or
without agoraphobia and their age- and sex-matched patients with a DSM
-III-R diagnosis of primary insomnia were examined for 3 consecutive n
ights of sleep in the laboratory. To measure anxiety und depression we
used the appropriate Hamilton Scales (HAMA and HAMD). Despite signifi
cant differences in the sleep parameters with respect to the number of
stage shifts, the number of nocturnal awakenings, stage 1 and the per
centage of total REM-sleep only minimal differences between both diagn
ostic groups were found. Patients with panic disorder or primary insom
nia showed a marked first-night-effect from night one to night three t
hat was an adaptation to the research conditions found in the sleep la
boratory. The first-night recordings differed from those of the third
night by prolonged sleep onset latency, reduced total sleep time, dist
urbed sleep continuation, prolonged REM-latency and reduction in perce
ntage of REM sleep. Differences in the first-night-effect could not be
assessed between diagnostic groups. The polysomnographic findings sup
port the hypothesis that in patients with panic disorder as well as in
those with primary insomnia the observed sleep disturbances may be du
e to underlying, but not specific mechanisms, and probably also reflec
t marked inter-individual differences of sleep.