Bm. Wildemuth et Me. Moore, END-USER SEARCH BEHAVIORS AND THEIR RELATIONSHIP TO SEARCH EFFECTIVENESS, Bulletin of the Medical Library Association, 83(3), 1995, pp. 294-304
One hundred sixty-one MEDLINE searches conducted by third-year medical
students were analyzed and evaluated to determine which search moves
were used, whether those individual moves were effective, and whether
there was a relationship between specific search behaviors and the eff
ectiveness of the search strategy as a whole. The typical search inclu
ded fourteen search statements, used seven terms or ''limit'' commands
, and resulted in the display of eleven citations. The most common mov
es were selection of a database, entering single-word terms and free-t
ext term phrases, and combining sets of terms. Syntactic errors were a
lso common. Overall, librarians judged the searches to be adequate, an
d students were quite satisfied with their own searches. However, libr
arians also identified many missed opportunities in the search strateg
ies, including underutilization of the controlled vocabulary, subheadi
ngs, and synonyms for search concepts. No strong relationships were fo
und between specific search behaviors and search effectiveness (as mea
sured by the librarians' or students' evaluations). Implications of th
ese findings for system design and user education are discussed.