F. Baeyens et J. Dehouwer, EVALUATIVE CONDITIONING IS A QUALITATIVELY DISTINCT FORM OF CLASSICAL-CONDITIONING - REPLY, Behaviour research and therapy, 33(7), 1995, pp. 825-831
Based on a critical review of the literature, Davey (1994)-[Behaviour
Research and Therapy, 32, 291-299] concludes that there is no sufficie
nt evidence to support the theoretical position that evaluative condit
ioning is a qualitatively different form of classical conditioning. In
the present manuscript, we will try to show that Davey's conclusion i
s biased by: (a) an overemphasis on what he believes to be problematic
procedural aspects of previous evaluative conditioning studies; and (
b) a selective reading of the available evidence. Finally, an attempt
is made to characterize evaluative conditioning phenomena as the outpu
t of a Referential Learning System, which can be distinguished from an
Expectancy Learning System.