Ph. Ditto et al., BELIEFS ABOUT PHYSICIANS - THEIR ROLE IN HEALTH-CARE UTILIZATION, SATISFACTION, AND COMPLIANCE, Basic and applied social psychology, 17(1-2), 1995, pp. 23-48
Although the most prominent social psychological models of health beha
vior are expectancy based, little attention has been paid to the role
of individuals' beliefs about physicians in the utilization and evalua
tion of health care. Three studies suggest that individuals' beliefs a
bout whether physicians should adopt an authoritarian or egalitarian r
ole in health care interactions are related to health care utilization
, satisfaction, and compliance. In Study 1, we found that authoritaria
n role expectations were associated with more self-reported visits to
medical professionals in a sample of college undergraduates. In Study
2, we examined a sample of elderly outpatients and found that authorit
arian beliefs were associated with objective indicators of greater hea
lth care utilization. In Study 3, we had undergraduates with authorita
rian or egalitarian role expectations read a vignette in which a physi
cian displayed either an authoritarian or egalitarian communication st
yle. Although all subjects reported greater liking for the egalitarian
than the authoritarian physician, egalitarian belief subjects reporte
d being particularly dissatisfied with the authoritarian physician and
reported particularly weak intentions of following the authoritarian
physician's treatment prescriptions. These results suggest that indivi
duals' subjective beliefs about medical professionals are an important
determinant of health-related behaviors and perceptions.