GRANULOCYTE-COLONY-STIMULATING FACTOR VERSUS PLACEBO IN ADDITION TO PENICILLIN-G IN A RANDOMIZED BLINDED STUDY OF GRAM-NEGATIVE PNEUMONIA SEPSIS - ANALYSIS OF SURVIVAL AND MULTISYSTEM ORGAN FAILURE
Ws. Smith et al., GRANULOCYTE-COLONY-STIMULATING FACTOR VERSUS PLACEBO IN ADDITION TO PENICILLIN-G IN A RANDOMIZED BLINDED STUDY OF GRAM-NEGATIVE PNEUMONIA SEPSIS - ANALYSIS OF SURVIVAL AND MULTISYSTEM ORGAN FAILURE, Blood, 86(4), 1995, pp. 1301-1309
Sepsis is a common cause of morbidity and mortality. Neutrophils are t
he major defense against bacterial invasion, and granulocyte colony-st
imulating factor (G-CSF) augments both neutrophil number and function.
In our study, 160 rabbits were inoculated transtracheally with 0.5 mL
of a solution containing 10(4) colony forming units per milliliter of
Pasteurella multocida. Twenty-four hours later, chest xrays and quant
itative blood cultures demonstrated pneumonia and bacteremia. Therapy
was then begun with penicillin G and either recombinant human G-CSF (r
G-CSF; 5 to 8 mu g/ kg subcutaneously) or placebo every day for 5 days
. Arterial blood gases and 23 other parameters of organ function were
performed before inoculation and serially thereafter. All rabbits unde
rwent histologic examination of organs at the time of septic death or
when sacrificed on day 6. A total of 149 rabbits survived long enough
to initiate therapy. A significant increase in leukocytes by day 4 was
found in the rG-CSF-treated group. There was a trend towards improved
survival in the rG-CSF group (77% v 67%; P = .13, n = 149). Analysis
of pretreatment variables revealed sepsis-induced leukopenia (less tha
n or equal to 2,800/mu L) as the only predictor of significantly impro
ved survival with rG-CSF treatment (57% v 39%; P = .04, n = 73). The m
ajority of the survival benefit occurred within the first 24 hours of
treatment. This was before the time that a significant difference in m
ean white blood cell (WBC) count was observed between the study groups
, making intravascular leukocytosis an unlikely explanation for the su
rvival advantage in the rG-CSF group. No significant difference in lab
oratory variables reflecting organ function was demonstrated between t
he groups. Histologic grading of inflammation (0, normal, to 6, necros
is) in seven organs revealed that the surviving rabbits had mild but s
tatistically significant increased inflammation in the liver, spleen,
and noninoculated lung in the rG-CSF versus placebo groups (liver: 2.6
v 1.5, P less than or equal to .0001; spleen: 3.2 v 2.3, P less than
or equal to .0001; and noninoculated lung: 2.9 v 2.5, P = .04). Admini
stration of rG-CSF, in addition to penicillin G, in immune competent r
abbits with gram-negative sepsis complicated by leukopenia significant
ly improved survival over antibiotics alone. The administration of rG-
CSF in early sepsis for a short therapeutic duration was not associate
d with any clinically evident toxicity. Clinical trials using rG-CSF i
n septic patients with leukopenia are indicated.