A SMART MONTE-CARLO TECHNIQUE FOR FREE-ENERGY SIMULATIONS OF MULTICONFORMATIONAL MOLECULES, DIRECT CALCULATIONS OF THE CONFORMATIONAL POPULATIONS OF ORGANIC-MOLECULES
H. Senderowitz et al., A SMART MONTE-CARLO TECHNIQUE FOR FREE-ENERGY SIMULATIONS OF MULTICONFORMATIONAL MOLECULES, DIRECT CALCULATIONS OF THE CONFORMATIONAL POPULATIONS OF ORGANIC-MOLECULES, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 117(31), 1995, pp. 8211-8219
Metropolis Monte Carlo (MMC) can be a highly inefficient simulation te
chnique when only a small fraction of an energy surface is populated a
nd barriers between low-energy regions are high. In such cases, previo
us knowledge of the surface (e.g. low-energy conformations of molecule
s) can be used to preferentially sample the significantly populated re
gions. In this work we present a new MC method for accomplishing this
goal. We term the method JBW for Jumping Between Wells. The JBW proced
ure operates by locating the various conformations of a molecule and s
ubsequently driving an MMC-like simulation to jump repeatedly between
them. Using simulations on 1- and 2-dimensional potential surfaces and
on n-pentane, the JBW method is shown to generate ensembles of states
that are indistinguishable from the canonical ensembles generated by
classical MMC in the limit. Integration of JBW into the recently descr
ibed MC/SD hybrid simulation algorithm enables rapidly converged simul
ations of conformationally flexible molecules including cyclic molecul
es in all degrees of freedom. The new method (MC(JBW)/SD) gives conver
ged comformational populations at a rate that is essentially independe
nt of the energy barriers between conformations, We use the method to
evaluate free energy differences between the conformers of various sub
stituted cyclohexanes and of the larger ring hydrocarbons cycloheptane
, cyclooctane, cyclononane and cyclodecane on several widely used pote
ntial energy surfaces. Such conformational free energies are compared
with simple molecular mechanics steric energies both with and without
rigid rotor-harmonic oscillator free energy corrections. In general, w
e find that assumptions of harmonicity do not lead to good approximati
ons of the actual anharmonic free energies. In the case of cyclohexane
derivatives at room temperature, the MC(JBW)/SD method is estimated t
o generate converged ensembles of all conformations at a rate similar
to 10(6) times faster than methods based on simple molecular or stocha
stic dynamics.