Objective. To evaluate the prevalence of psoriatic arthritis (PsA) in
Italian patients with psoriasis and to compare the Moll and Wright cri
teria, the European Spondylarthropathy Study Group (ESSG) criteria, an
d Amor criteria when applied to this patient population. Methods. We e
xamined 205 unselected patients with psoriasis. The diagnosis of PsA w
as based upon the clinical experience of a rheumatologist. After, we t
ested these classification criteria. HLA class I and II antigens were
also analyzed. Results. Thirty-six percent (75) of psoriatic patients
were considered by a clinical expert to have PsA. Moll and Wright crit
eria identified 46 patients (22%) with PsA; 49 patients (24%) were ide
ntified by ESSG criteria and Amor criteria; 12 patients identified by
Amor criteria but not by ESSG criteria presented enthesitis or dactyli
tis; 10 patients identified by ESSG but not by Amor criteria had perip
heral synovitis. In patients with peripheral arthritis and psoriasis,
the evaluation of NSAID response was critical to fulfilling Amor crite
ria. However, it was not easy to retrospectively evaluate NSAID respon
se using these criteria. The sensitivity was low for each of the 3 cla
ssification criteria (from 61 to 65%), whereas the specificity was hig
h (from 99 to 100%). Conclusion. Our study confirms a high prevalence
of PsA among an unselected population of Italian patients with psorias
is. Our data reveal the inadequacy of the existing criteria for PsA, i
ncluding the ESSG criteria and Amor criteria for the classification of
spondyloarthropathy.