B. Vreman et al., A-PRIORI TESTS OF LARGE-EDDY SIMULATION OF THE COMPRESSIBLE PLANE MIXING LAYER, Journal of engineering mathematics, 29(4), 1995, pp. 299-327
Three important aspects for the assessment of the possibilities of Lar
ge Eddy Simulation (LES) of compressible flow are investigated. In par
ticular the magnitude of all subgrid-terms, the role of the discretiza
tion errors and the correlation of the turbulent stress tenser with se
veral subgrid-models are studied. The basis of the investigation is a
Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) of the two- and three-dimensional co
mpressible mixing layer, using a finite volume method on a sufficientl
y fine grid. With respect to the first aspect, the exact filtered Navi
er-Stokes equations are derived and all terms are classified according
to their order of magnitude. It is found that the pressure dilatation
subgrid-term in the filtered energy equation, which is usually neglec
ted in the modelling-practice, is as large as e.g, the pressure veloci
ty subgrid-term, which in general is modelled. The second aspect yield
s the result that second- and fourth-order accurate spatial discretiza
tion methods give rise to discretization errors which are larger than
the corresponding subgrid-terms, if the ratio between the filter width
and the grid-spacing is close to one. Even if an exact representation
for the subgrid-scale contributions is assumed, LES performed on a (c
onsiderably) coarser grid than required for a DNS, is accurate only if
this ratio is sufficiently larger than one. Finally the well-known tu
rbulent stress tenser is investigated in more detail. A priori tests o
f subgrid-models for this tenser yield poor correlations for Smagorins
ky's model, which is purely dissipative, while the non-eddy viscosity
models considered here correlate considerably better.