Nonstationary stochastic periodic review inventory problems with propo
rtional costs occur in a number of industrial settings with seasonal p
atterns, trends, business cycles, and limited life items. Myopic polic
ies for such problems order as if the salvage value in the current per
iod for ending inventory were the full purchase price, so that informa
tion about the future would not be needed. They have been shown in the
Literature to be optimal when demand ''is increasing over time,'' and
to provide upper bounds for the stationary finite horizon problem (an
d in some other situations). Some results are also known, given specia
l salvaging assumptions, about lower bounds on the optimal policy whic
h are near-myopic. Here analogous but stronger bounds are derived for
the general finite horizon problem, without such special assumptions.
The best upper bound is an extension of the heuristic used by industry
for some years for end of season (EOS) problems; the lower bound is a
n extension of earlier analytic methods. Four heuristics were tested a
gainst the optimal obtained by stochastic dynamic programming for 969
problems. The simplest heuristic is the myopic heuristic itself: it is
good especially for moderately varying problems without heavy end of
season salvage costs and averages only 2.75% in cost over the optimal.
However, the best of the heuristics exceeds the optimal in cost by an
average of only 0.02%, at about 0.5% of the computational cost of dyn
amic programming.