J. Baker et Rc. Newton, EXPERIMENTALLY DETERMINED ACTIVITY-COMPOSITION RELATIONS FOR CA-RICH SCAPOLITE IN THE SYSTEM CAAL2SI2O8-NAALSI3O8-CACO3 AT 7 KBAR, The American mineralogist, 80(7-8), 1995, pp. 744-751
Equilibrium compositions of coexisting Ca-rich carbonate scapolite and
plagioclase in the presence of calcite have been investigated experim
entally at 7.0 kbar in the temperature range 775-850 degrees C. The Ca
O-Al2O3-SiO2-CO2 univariant reaction is [GRAPHICS] with NaSi(CaAl)(-1)
substitution in both plagioclase and scapolite in the Na2O-CaO-Al2O3-
SiO2-CO2 divariant assemblage. The experiments were carried out in a 3
/4 in. diameter NaCl pressure cell with a hematite + magnetite buffer
and a hydrous oxalic acid flux. Starting materials were a natural Cl-
and S-free mizzonite (Me(63)), Baker reagent precipitated calcite, and
synthetic meionite and plagioclases of composition An(100) and An(92)
. Changes of compositions of the reactants were determined by micropro
be analysis. The experimental results confirm the inferences based on
observations in natural assemblages made by earlier workers that Na su
bstitution greatly stabilizes scapolite relative to plagioclase. The m
arked stabilization of mizzonite to lower temperatures is largely a co
nsequence of the large amounts of atomic mixing possible in the scapol
ite structure. An activity model for the meionite component in terms o
f its mole fraction, X(Me), which involves complete disordering of Ca
and Na and, independently, Si and Al, has been derived from the experi
mental brackets a(Me) = (1 + X(Me))(6)(3 - X(Me))(6)(3X(Me) + 1)(4)/4(
10) exp [-13450/T X(Me)(1 - X(Me))(2)]. This formula may lose validity
in a lower temperature range if scapolite develops greater atomic ord
ering near the mizzonite composition. The disordered scapolite model i
s used to calculate apparent CO2 activities for recrystallization of s
ome Grenville granulites studied by Moecher and Essene (1991). We find
close agreement with their predicted CO2 activities based on scapolit
e + garnet + plagioclase + quartz equilibrium at 800 degrees C and 10
kbar, despite the different scapolite activity models used in the two
sets of calculations. The simplest explanation of this coincidence is
that their empirical scapolite model and the present experimentally ba
sed model are both valid, although the latter is restricted to high te
mperatures (above 750 degrees C).