Sb. Engelsen et al., INTERNAL MOTIONS OF CARBOHYDRATES AS PROBED BY COMPARATIVE MOLECULAR MODELING AND NUCLEAR-MAGNETIC-RESONANCE OF ETHYL BETA-LACTOSIDE, Journal of computational chemistry, 16(9), 1995, pp. 1096-1119
The realization that conformational flexibility must be incorporated i
nto the description of the structural and dynamical behavior of carboh
ydrates has stimulated the quest for an appropriate force field and as
sociated parameterization capable of dealing with the many specific fe
atures of these molecules. Accordingly, we set out to evaluate the cap
acity of very different force fields to reproduce a series of experime
ntal spectral data such as optical rotatory dispersion, coupling const
ants, and nuclear Overhauser effects. NOESY volumes and long-range hom
onuclear and heteronuclear vicinal coupling constants were measured at
400.13 MHz. Optical rotation measurements were also performed on ethy
l beta-lactoside. The conformational behavior of ethyl beta-lactoside
was investigated in three different molecular mechanics force fields l
eading to three complete ensembles of theoretical conformations, which
were used for evaluating these statistically averaged observables. Th
e calculations of optical rotation followed a recent model based on in
teracting oscillators. Coupling constants were calculated using the ap
propriate sets of Karplus-type equations, and theoretical nuclear magn
etic resonance (NMR) relaxation data were obtained for models which ac
count for either slow or fast internal motions. The calculated potenti
al energy surfaces were shown to be dependent on the type of force fie
ld, even in the case of such a simple disaccharide. They differ in sev
eral respects, including the number and location of low-energy conform
ers and the shallowness of the dominant primary region. It was possibl
e to assess the different time-averaged orientations about the glycosi
dic linkage of the three force fields from the fit obtained for the in
terglycosidic heteronuclear coupling constants. Poor fits between theo
retical and experimental NOESY volumes were observed for all three for
ce fields when the slow internal motion model was used, while a greatl
y improved fit was obtained when the fast internal motions model was a
pplied. It has been shown that the motional model established from NOE
SY data is analogous to the one obtained from molecular dynamics simul
ations. The quality of the fit for the NOESY data varies with the forc
e fields and corroborates the classification obtained from heteronucle
ar coupling. (C) 1995 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.