N. Kunzli et al., ASSOCIATION BETWEEN LIFETIME AMBIENT OZONE EXPOSURE AND PULMONARY-FUNCTION IN COLLEGE-FRESHMEN - RESULTS OF A PILOT-STUDY, Environmental research, 72(1), 1997, pp. 8-23
Human health effects due to chronic exposure to ozone (O-3) have not b
een established due to problems with exposure assignment and the use o
f measures of lung function which may not reflect the site of O-3 toxi
city in the lung. We investigated the feasibility of retrospective ass
essment of O-3 exposure-relevant covariates and derived lifetime ''eff
ective exposure'' to ozone. Mid- and end-expiratory hows (FEF25-75%, F
EF75%) were regressed against effective exposure and ecological lifeti
me exposure. A convenience sample of 130 UC Berkeley freshmen, ages 17
-21, participated twice in the same tests (residential history, questi
onnaire, pulmonary function), 5-7 days apart. Students had to be lifel
ong residents of Northern (SF) or Southern (LA) California. Monthly am
bient O-3 concentrations (OZ) were assigned based on the lifetime resi
dential history. An ''effective time'' (T) spent in OZ environments wa
s derived for each residence and age stratum (0-2, 3-5, 6-11, 12+) wit
h the use of questions about ''total time spent outdoors'' and time sp
ent in ''moderate'' and/or ''heavy'' activity. Effective exposure was
calculated over the lifetime (OZ x T) of each subject. Ozone metrics u
sed were 8-hr averages (10 AM-6 PM) and ''hours above 60 ppb.'' FEF25-
75% and FEF75% decreased with both effective exposure and ecologic ass
ignment of O-3 exposure. For a 20 ppb increase (interquartile range) i
n 8-hr O-3 FEF75% decreased 334 ml/sec (95% Cl:11-657 ml/sec), which c
orresponds to 14% (1.0-28.3%) of the population mean FEF75%. The corre
sponding effect on FEF25-75% was -420 ml/sec (95% Cl: +46 to -886, P =
0.08) or 7.2% of the mean. Use of time-activity data to define exposu
re had no impact on estimates. Negative confounding factors were regio
n (SF vs LA), gender, and ethnicity. Lifetime 8-hr average O-3 concent
rations ranged from 16 to 74 ppb with little overlap between regions.
There was no evidence for different O-3 effects across regions. Effect
s were independent of lifetime mean PM(10), NO2, temperature, or humid
ity. Effects on FEV1 tended to be negative whereas those for FVC, alth
ough negative in some models, where inconsistent and small. The strong
relationship of lifetime ambient O-3 on mid- and end-expiratory flows
of college freshmen and the lack of association with FEV1 and FVC are
consistent with biologic models of chronic effects of O-3 in the smal
l airways. Since the present study was designed as a pilot study, thes
e findings have to be confirmed in a larger sample that is representat
ive of the target population. (C) 1997 Academic Press