Phenolics in marine brown algae have been thought to follow a latitudi
nal gradient with high phenolic species in high latitudes and low phen
olic species in low latitudes. However, tropical brown algae from the
western Caribbean have been shown to be high in phlorotannin concentra
tion, indicating that latitude alone is not a reasonable predictor of
marine plant phenolic concentrations. This study shows that the range
of high phenolic phaeophytes is not limited to the western Caribbean b
ut encompasses the western tropical Atlantic, including Bermuda and th
e Caribbean, where algal phlorotannin concentrations can be as high as
25% dry weight (DW). Assimilation efficiencies (AEs) of phenolic-rich
and phenolic-poor plants were examined in three tropical marine herbi
vores (the parrotfish, Sparisoma radians, and the brachyuran crab, Mit
hrax sculptus, from Belize and the parrotfish, Sparisoma chrysopterum,
from Bermuda). AEs of phenolic-rich food by each of the three herbivo
re species were uniformly high, suggesting that high plant phenolic co
ncentrations did not affect AEs in these species. This is in contrast
to some temperate marine herbivores where phenolic concentrations of 1
0% DW have been shown to drastically reduce AE. The apparent contradic
tion is discussed in light of the effects of specific herbivore gut ch
aracteristics on successful herbivory of high phenolic brown algae.