H. Rubin et al., NEOPLASTIC DEVELOPMENT - PARADOXICAL RELATION BETWEEN IMPAIRED CELL-GROWTH AT LOW POPULATION-DENSITY AND EXCESSIVE GROWTH AT HIGH-DENSITY, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United Statesof America, 92(17), 1995, pp. 7734-7738
The role of heritable, population-wide cell damage in neoplastic devel
opment was studied in the 28 L subline of NTH 3T3 cells, These cells d
iffer from the 17(3c) subline used previously for such studies in thei
r lower frequency of ''spontaneous'' transformation at high population
density and their greater capacity to produce large, dense transforme
d foci. Three cultures of the 28 L subline of NM 3T3 cells were held u
nder the constraint of confluence for 5 wk (5 wk 1 degrees assay) and
then assayed twice in succession (2 degrees and 3 degrees assays) for
transformed foci and saturation density, After the 2 degrees assay, th
e cells were also passaged at low density to determine their exponenti
al growth rates and cloned to determine the size and morphological fea
tures of the colonies, Concurrent measurements were made in each case
with control cells that had beep kept only in frequent low-density pas
sages and cells that had been kept at confluence for only 2 wk (2 wk 1
degrees), Two of the three cultures transferred from the 2 degrees as
say of the 5 wk 1 degrees cultures produced light transformed foci, an
d the third produced dense foci, The light focus-forming cultures grew
to twice the control saturation density ip their 2 degrees assay and
6-8 times the control density in the 3 degrees assay; saturation densi
ties for the dense focus formers were about 10 times the control value
s in both assays, All three of the cultures transferred from the 2 deg
rees assay of the 5 wk 1 degrees cultures multiplied at lower rates th
an controls at low densities, but the dense focus formers multiplied f
aster than the light focus formers, The reduced rates of multiplicatio
n of the light focus formers persisted for >50 generations of exponent
ial multiplication at low densities. Isolated colonies formed from sin
gle cells of the light focus formers were of a lower population densit
y than controls; colonies formed by the dense focus formers were sligh
tly denser than the controls but occupied only half the area A much hi
gher proportion of the colonies from the 5 wk 1 degrees cultures than
the controls consisted of giant cells or mixtures of giant and normal-
appearing cells. The results reinforce the previous conclusion that th
e early increases in saturation density and light focus formation are
associated with, and perhaps caused by, heritable, population-wide dam
age to cells that is essentially epigenetic in nature. The more advanc
ed transformation characterized by large increases in saturation densi
ty and dense focus formation could have originated from rare genetic c
hanges, such as chromosome rearrangements, known to occur at an elevat
ed frequency in cells destabilized by antecedent cellular damage.